Showing posts with label global technology and outsourcing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global technology and outsourcing. Show all posts

Monday, May 10, 2010

“The 4E Principal” for Determining an Outsourcing Partner

As a member of the Scientific Advisory Board of Sciformix (www.sciformix.com), the management team thought it would be useful if we were to describe the case for doing business with their company, the value proposition and the practical reasons that accounts for the success of their business. I thought it may be useful to our readership to republish this and share some of our thoughts.

Describing why outsourcing/out-tasking is such a huge success is a straightforward challenge. It is rooted far more deeply than labor arbitrage which is the core reason most companies choose to use an outsourcing “partner”. There are unprecedented shifts in the way Bio-pharmaceutical companies are conducting their business today, partially forced by macroeconomics, politics, population growth and aging and the “flattening” of the globe that provides opportunity and challenge unknown before today.


There is an enormous pressure on management to perform the concurrent miracle of significant cost reductions coupled with simultaneous productivity improvements in order to thrive in our business. While workloads are inexorably increasing, there are daily headlines describing massive layoffs and facility closings in our industry. No corner of the business, regardless of the geography is immune from these pressures.


One of the few growth areas for budgets is the amount of outsourcing/out-tasking/off shoring that the Bio-Pharmaceutical Industry has undertaken. While the industry has been late out of the starting blocks, the lost time is being rapidly made up. Variations on the theme are diverse and include captive centers, joint ventures with global outsourcing companies, the major expansion of use of Clinical Research Organizations (CRO's), use of diverse geographies and any other creative aspects companies can create.



Our point here is to outline four key areas of consideration for outsourcing the drug safety and adjacent functions to a company such as Sciformix. We call it “The 4E Principal” which encompasses the “whys” of doing business together, each company's priorities will differ. The 4E's are Effectiveness, Efficiency, Economics and Employees and we will describe what we mean by each of these:


Effectiveness: In the area of drug safety, effectiveness encompasses results that are of high quality, compliant with appropriate regulations, consistent from batch to batch and well documented. With the large variation in the number and kind of testing that needs to be done and the education updates that are required, it is a significant challenge for the sponsor company to comply effectively. As Sciformix is focused on this area, day after day, the effectiveness we bring to your company is likely to be significantly better than you experience today.





Efficiency: Ideally your lab is running at or near 100%, however the reality is such that “peaks and valleys” are the norm profoundly impacting productivity and increasing unit costs. As a specialized outsourcing partner, companies such as Sciformix provide a predictable, attractively priced alternative to the classic in house staff-many companies tend to adapt a hybrid model that couples both in house expertise with external capability and bandwidth.





Economics: The economics of external drug safety capability are driven by labor arbitrage, that is to say that if external costs are less than 50% of that of in house capability and quality is equal to or better than current models, than the decision is very straightforward. As with investment policies in the financial world, 90% of the value is achieved with the initial decision, further incremental economic benefits are possible, but not as compelling once the major decision to go external is made. Currently, Sciformix can demonstrate cost benefits of greater than 50% compared with either in house or on shore based providers while providing a superior result.





Employees: The key driver for having an external provider for drug safety functions is based on the cost and upkeep of employees-including non-productive time, continuing education, vacations, holidays, benefits, etc. all of which add up to high overhead costs that are virtually eliminated when working with Sciformix.

Sunday, March 1, 2009

We Talk with Some Renowned Attorneys about the Satyam Scandal, India and the Future of Outsourcing

We have discussed our thoughts about the outsourcing business and its viability over the last few months and had a real opportunity to have two highly regarded attorneys discuss their point of view about the global outsourcing business in general and the impact of the Satyam financial scandal in particular.

Larry and I had a wide ranging discussion with Randy Parks and Jim Harvey, attorneys at Hunton & Williams LLP and co-chairs of its Global Technology and Outsourcing practice about the impact of the Satyam affair on global outsourcing. Hunton & Williams is a very large and well respected law firm with over 1,000 attorneys in nineteen offices worldwide. The Black Book of Outsourcing (http://theblackbookofoutsourcing.com/ ) ranks them as the number one outsourcing law firm in the world. Randy and Jim focus on the customer side of outsourcing deals although they have done some suppliers. This is the first of three blogs from this interview.

We asked Randy’s and Jim’s about their impressions of the Satyam affair. Interestingly, Randy started by saying that he was disappointed by Satyam's behavior. Satyam had been a fantastic story, from nothing to a star in the globalization outsourcing market in ten to fifteen years and now to have to take a big black eye over this. He continued by saying that many Indian firms get higher customer satisfaction scores than firms based in the U.S. and emphasized that one bad apple doesn’t spoil the whole industry-he specifically pointed out that Enron was a single company disaster that did not permeate the entire energy industry.

We next moved onto what the warning signs were at Satyam, if any. First and foremost from our discussion was their reply that it would have been very difficult for a client to detect the fraud that was occurring-so we infer that best defense is a good offense-see their recommendations below. Jim stated that on a chronological time line (retrospectively) there were signs at a corporate level that some things were amiss. First, there had been rumors of a data breach at the World Bank, later found to be baseless, followed by the attempted sham real estate transaction. Randy also asked how they managed to keep $700 million in a bank without earning any interest and noted that the CFO deflected a reporter's query on this matter.

They explained to us that it wasn’t reasonable to expect customers to have the visibility to an outsourcer’s business to permit the type of transparency necessary to detect a fraud such as Satyam’s. Further, additional protection costs a significant amount of money and effort, and, then, would they work?

Randy and Jim agreed that developing a theoretical business model to protect against this type of situation would be an interesting intellectual exercise but wouldn’t be practical.

The next topic that we discussed was the lessons learned from the Satyam affair. Randy and Jim stressed operational execution of contract terms with outsourcers was and is the key to protecting a client from such issues, and even these are not entirely fool proof. They gave five recommendations that would be of use to our readers:

• Diversify the vendor pool-have a minimum of 3 suppliers.
• Take care of the data by offsite backups, assume catastrophic failure.
• Have source code drops.
• Manage the vendor relationships-enforce and exercise the contract terms.
• Take possession of dedicated machines.

Now, the caveat with these approaches is that they lower the anticipated savings expected from outsourcing deals. For example, the last point talks about dedicated machines which would cost more than shared machines. Randy and Jim noted that many contracts have these terms included but customers don’t exercise them. (I was polite and didn’t point out that such customers lose a second time because they’ve also paid their attorneys to draft such contracts and don’t use them properly.)

TO BE CONTINUED.

As always, we welcome your feedback. Please contact us at larryrothmansblog@gmail.com. We look forward to hearing from you.

Contributed by Guy de Lastin